I ditched Bloglines the other day for Google Reader. I'm not a huge fan of Bloglines' new beta interface, most because I find it clunkier than the current interface. Sure, the current one feels a little dated, but it works. Plus, the iPhone interface is nice. Google has a lot going for it. For one, it seems everyone who uses it raves about it. Also, the iPhone interface is integrated with all the other Google services I use, Picasa Web, Gmail, etc.
This all came about because I wanted to use a desktop RSS reader at home and sync it with my web interface for work and iPhone, but that doesn't exist unless I use Newsgator. Bloglines and Google both appear to have a sync API, but neither Vienna nor NetNewsWire (nor any other client I could find) actually syncs back to them.
But it appears Vienna is working on one for Google's reader, and with the Bloglines beta looming, it seemed like a good enough time to make the jump. So I did.
Google's Reader is awfully attractive, but it's really keyboard driven. Not only that, but there's no way to have it mark all items as read as you click a feed. You must begin the tedious task of scrolling through every single item, or hitting "j", "j", "j". And YouTube embeds don't go away - at least in Opera 9.22 - they just wait at the top of the reading pane, obstructing text, until I click a new feed.
Did I mention that Google Reader is slow slow slow? I can click a link and watch it "Loading..." for several seconds. Opera is a second class citizen in Google-land, which is why all new Gmail features don't work (v2, label colors, AIM) and Picasa support is flaky, but I think Reader fits in that boat too. It's painful.
So, after 4 full days, I bailed. I'm back to Bloglines classic. I'd love to tweak the stylesheet a little, but it works and it's so much faster. I'm pretty pleased with Bloglines, especially now that I've had a chance to experience something else.
Tags: Bloglines, Google, Google Reader, RSS, Gmail, Switch, Web 2.0
Comments
